In Hong Kong, the use of electronic signatures (e-signatures) is generally recognized and legally binding as per the Electronic Transactions Ordinance (ETO). This means that directors of a company can use e-signatures to sign audited financial statements, as long as they comply with the requirements stipulated in the ETO. However, the use of e-signatures is not without risk and there are certain considerations to be taken into account.
The ETO sets out the basic requirements for e-signatures as follows:
The e-signature must be attached to, or logically associated with, the electronic message.
The e-signature process must be reliable as is appropriate given the purpose for which the signature is required.
The recipient must consent to the signatory using an e-signature.
However, the ETO also outlines certain documents that are not suitable for e-signatures, including powers of attorney, documents concerning land and property transactions, oaths and affidavits, statutory declarations, and testamentary documents such as wills. E-signatures should also be avoided where any documents need to be registered or filed with a regulator that requires an original wet ink signature or where the document needs to be notarized.
Now, let's look at the specific case of audited financial statements. The Hong Kong Companies Ordinance requires a company's directors to prepare financial statements for each financial year. These financial statements must comply with the Hong Kong Financial Reporting Standards and must be audited.
The use of e-signatures for financial statements is not expressly mentioned in the Companies Ordinance, which leaves room for interpretation. While it's not common practice in Hong Kong for such important documents to be executed using e-signatures, they could potentially be used if they comply with the ETO requirements. However, as this is not yet tested in the Hong Kong courts, there is a degree of uncertainty until case law develops or legislation is amended to confirm the position.
Before using e-signatures for important legal documents, you should consider the following:
Check whether the document is permitted under the ETO to be signed electronically.
Consider if the document will be used in a jurisdiction which affords less evidentiary credibility to electronic documents.
Ensure the e-signature adequately identifies the signatory and gives sufficient indication of the signatory’s approval of the agreement or information to which it relates.
Ensure that their e-signature systems are sufficiently reliable and secure.
Consider which party will coordinate signing and issue invitations to the other signatories.
Consider the steps to be taken after a document is executed, e.g., maintaining a printed or soft copy version of the document.
In conclusion, while it's technically possible for directors to sign audited financial statements through e-signatures in Hong Kong, given the legal considerations and potential risks, it would be advisable to consult with a legal expert before proceeding.
댓글